Suddenly Amish

The Evil One

TV-14
S1 • E5    Feb 10, 2026    43m
6.6
The Bishop hears firsthand accounts exposing hidden truths unfolding within his community. Cousins James and Emma reveal a shocking secret at a party. Matt and Kendra risk everything as they set off to break one of the Amish's most sacred rules.

Where to Watch Suddenly Amish - S1 • E5

Cast of The Evil One

  • AllenSelf
  • Kendra BatesSelf
  • EsmeraldaSelf
  • Billie JoSelf
  • JudahSelf
  • Aaron NobleSelf
  • Emma TroyerSelf
  • James TroyerSelf
  • VernonSelf
  • Alexander BlockExecutive Producer
  • Jack ColeExecutive Producer
  • Eric EvangelistaExecutive Producer
  • Shannon EvangelistaExecutive Producer
  • Mark BarragatoEditor
  • Michael BartolomeoEditor
  • Steven MattyEditor
  • Liz OakesSupervising Producer

 

  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   

Take Plex everywhere

Watch free anytime, anywhere, on almost any device.
See the full list of supported devices